Captain Jack taking his frustration out on Monkey Jack.
Raghetti "reading" the Bible.
Pintel and Raghetti fawning all over Jack.
Elizabeth's wedding gown marionette.
The pirates' reaction to Jack ordering them to use the rum with the gunpowder.
Barbossa's five-second scene, especially since he was eating one of his beloved apples. The next movie's going to be such a hoot with him in it!
Davy Jones' variation of the Black Spot.
The cannibals were pointless.
Combining Davy Jones and the legend of the Flying Dutchman, especially since Jones' boat doesn't even fly.
Tia Dalma's accent. I had a hard time figuring out half the stuff she was saying.
Norrington betraying Jack and the others. Seeing him as a broken man fascinated me (such a 180 from the last movie), but betraying his crewmates was just wrong. I'm hoping he redeems himself in the next movie.